Tisdale and his wife dined at The Pink Magnolia on Bull Street, ordering two steaks, a seafood appetizer, two desserts, and a bottle of wine before exiting through a side door without paying the $204 bill. Rather than simply fleeing, the couple left behind a fully completed customer comment card rating their experience two out of five stars, critiquing the ribeye as ‘overdone,’ the server as ‘attentive but rushed,’ and noting that ‘for these prices the bread basket should be bottomless.’ They signed the card with their actual first names and, fatally, the loyalty rewards phone number provided when making the reservation. Per the detective: ‘They left a review. With their phone number. Under their real names. The feedback was, I will admit, fair regarding the bread. But you cannot critique a meal you are in the process of stealing.’ The restaurant has reportedly taken the bread feedback under advisement.